Source: Ryan ALM Pension Monitor Q1 2024
Through March 31, 2024
Pension plan liabilities need to be measured and monitored regularly. Without knowledge of plan liabilities, the allocation of plan assets cannot be done efficiently or appropriately. The funded ratio/status of pension plans are present value calculations. Each type of plan is governed by accounting rules and actuarial practices, which determine the discount rate used to calculate the present value of liabilities. Single employer corporate plans are under ASC 715 (FASB) discount rates (AA corporate zero-coupon yield curve); multiemployer plans and public plans use the ROA (return on asset assumption) as the liability discount rate. The difference in liability growth between these plans can be quite significant (see 2022’s differential of 31.5%), which will affect funded status and contribution levels, and it may lead to inappropriate decisions.
The table below compares these different liability growth rates (based on a 12-year average duration) versus the asset growth rate based on the P&I asset allocation survey of the top 1,000 plans which is updated annually.
| ASSET ALLOCATION | Q1’24 Return | Corporate | Public | Union |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Domestic Stock | 10.6% | 12.6% | 21.9% | 22.2% |
| International Stock | 5.9% | 6.3% | 13.6% | 9.9% |
| Global Equity | 8.3% | 5.7% | 5.4% | 11.6% |
| Domestic Fixed Income | -0.8% | 45.4% | 18.7% | 18.2% |
| Global Fixed Income | 3.0% | 0.6% | 1.6% | 0.4% |
| Cash | 1.2% | 2.2% | 1.9% | 0.9% |
| Private Equity | 2.7% | 8.7% | 15.0% | 12.3% |
| Real Estate Equity* | -3.4% | 4.8% | 10.8% | 9.7% |
| Other | 1.8% | 13.7% | 11.1% | 14.8% |
| TOTAL ASSETS Growth Rate | 2.2% | 3.7% | 4.1% | |
| LIABILITIES Growth Rate** | -1.5% | 1.8% | 1.8% | |
| Asset Growth – Liability Growth | 3.7% | 1.9% | 2.3% |
Index Benchmarks: Domestic Stock = S&P 500; Int’l Stock = EAFE, Global Equity = All Country World; Domestic Fixed Income = BB Aggregate; Global Fixed Income = FTSE World Gov’t (unhedged); Cash = Ryan ALM Cash Index; Private Equity = 10-year return for the R2500 + 2%; *Real estate Equity = NFI-DP Index (one month lag); Alternative Investments and Other = CPI-U & 3%.
** Liabilities (corporate) = Ryan ALM ASC 715 discount rate and Liabilities (Public, Multiemployer) = 7.25% ROA
The graph below shows the contrasting annual differences of asset versus liability growth for corporate and public plans since 2015. The impact of different accounting rules (FASB vs. GASB) can create confusion, as reflected in the chart below.
Footnote: The measurement of asset growth to liability growth is an annual calculation beginning on December 31, 2015. For periods shorter than 1-year, the observation is a YTD calculation.
With regard to Q1’24, Public pension funds (2.2%) underperformed Corporate Pension plans (3.7%) by 1.5% as ASC 715 discount rates showed a negative growth rate of -1.5% for Q1’24 while the discount rate using the average ROA would have appreciated by 1.8%. This outperformance by corporate pension plans was accomplished despite the much greater exposure to US fixed income within corporate pension plans (45.4%) versus both public (18.7%) and multiemployer (18.2%) and the far less exposure to US equities (12.6%) versus publics (21.9%) and multiemployer (22.2%) Public and multiemployer pension plans would have outperformed Corporate plans if the accounting rules that guide them allowed for a mark-to-market valuation of plan liabilities. We witnessed in 2022 how different accounting rules can have a major impact on a plan’s funded ratio/status.