Source: Pension Myth No 2: Contributions Are NOT an Asset (in the Funded Ratio)
The funded ratio is supposedly the acid test of a pension plan’s solvency. It is simply the present value of assets / present value of liabilities. But how the present value is calculated can beerroneous and misleading. Public and multiemployer plans smooth assets usually over five years. This could overvalue or undervalue such assets versus their market value. More important, liabilities are priced at the ROA as the GASB discount rate. This valuation methodology has created a serious economic disparity versus the market value of liabilities for many years. If we compare the FASB market value methodology of an AA corporate discount rate (ASC 715) to the average ROA used as the GASB discount rate (Source: Milliman) we can see this disparity quite clearly:
ROA – ASC 715 = yield disparity x liability duration = % disparity
6.75% - 4.71% = 2.04% x 12 years = 24.48%
(Sources: Milliman Study for ROA, Ryan ALM for ASC 715 discount rates)
The above exercise suggests that reported pension liabilities are about 25% lower than their true economic valuation if market rates (ASC 715) were used as the discount rates.
Contributions
But there is a more serious misrepresentation of the funded status, as Contributions are not included in the funded status calculation. This is done supposedly because contributions are not a certain future asset (but neither are projections of benefits and expenses certain liability amounts). The truth is:
Contributions are future assets
Contributions are the first source to fund benefits + expenses (liabilities)
Assets fund net liabilities = (benefits + expenses) – contributions, ((B+E) – C)
Actual contributions are usually 100% of the actuarial required contribution (ARC)
Net Liabilities
Assets need to know what they are funding… net liabilities. This includes expenses and contributions which are not included in the funded ratio. Only the asset exhaustion test (AET) focuses on net liabilities = (benefits + expenses) – contributions. Since contributions tend to be large, the funded status of most pensions is better than reported and may require a lower ROA if the ARC (annual required contribution) is paid. Ryan ALM calculates the proper ROA based on a modified AET. This calculated ROA based on net liabilities should be the hurdle rate for asset allocation and not an ROA based on an asset allocation model. This approach should better inform assets of their mission and eliminate the obvious disconnect of a 60% and 90% funded plan having the same ROA and asset allocation.