Pension Myth # 1: Earn the ROA… and All is Well

The return on assets (ROA) assumption is not based on the funded ratio or funded status. Instead, it is based on the expected return from the asset allocation model. As a result, the ROA is not a calculated return that will guarantee a fully funded status if achieved as a long-term return… nor will it guarantee that contributions will go down. In fact, contributions should go up if the pension plan has a deficit in the funded status. Some simple math can prove this point.

($ millions with ROA = 7.0%)

Year Asset MV Liability MV Funded Ratio Funded Status
$70.00 $100.00 70.0% -$30.00
1 74.90 107.00 70.0% -32.10
2 80.14 114.49 70.0% -34.35
3 85.75 122.50 70.0% -36.75
4 91.76 131.08 70.0% -39.32
5 98.18 140.26 70.0% -42.08

Public and Multiemployer plans use the ROA as the discount rate for liabilities. This means that assets and liabilities are expected to have the same % growth rate. However, if there is a deficit in the funded status (usually) there will be a difference in the $ growth rates. Accounting rules suggest that liabilities are to be viewed and priced as a portfolio of fixed income securities or annuities. This ROA discount rate for liabilities is in direct contradiction to the asset allocation model ROA estimate for fixed income which is the lowest ROA (next to Cash), as it is based on the current YTM of a bond index. In the exhibit above, the $ deficit grows by 7% per year (same as ROA) to 40.27% in just 5 years ($42.08 / $30.00) although the funded ratio stays consistent at 70%. This growing deficit must be funded through higher and higher contribution costs since assets are not outgrowing liabilities in $s and funded status.

Interestingly, GASB requires a test of solvency (asset exhaustion test) to document that the asset cash flows (at the ROA) will fully fund the net liability cash flows (benefits + expenses – contributions). Please note that GASB requires a comparison of asset cash flows (including contributions as future assets) versus net liability cash flows (including benefits + expenses). Ryan ALM enhances the asset exhaustion test by calculating the ROA that will fully fund net liability cash flows. Usually, we find that a lower ROA can accomplish this goal than the current ROA. This would suggest a more conservative asset allocation and a heavier allocation to fixed income to defease liability cash flows chronologically.

Ryan ALM Solutions:

Custom Liability Index (CLI): The first step in prudent pension management is to calculate the liability cash flows that assets must fund. This should be a net liability cash flow (benefits + expenses – contributions). Until liabilities are monitored and priced as a Custom Liability Index (CLI) the asset side is in jeopardy of managing to the wrong objectives (i.e. ROA and generic market indexes). Only a CLI best represents the unique liability cash flows of a plan sponsor. Just like snowflakes, no two pension liability schedules are alike due to different labor forces, salaries, mortality, and plan amendments. How could a static ROA or generic market indexes ever properly represent the risk/reward behavior of such a diverse array of pension liabilities? Once the CLI is installed, the pension will now know the true economic Funded Ratio and Funded Status, which should dictate the appropriate Asset Allocation, Asset Management, and Performance Measurement. Ron Ryan was the inventor of the first Custom Liability Index in 1991. In 2006, Ron won the William F. Sharpe Index Lifetime Achievement Award!

Liability Beta Portfolio™ (LBP): The intrinsic value in bonds is the certainty of its cash flows. That is why bonds have been used for decades to defease liability cash flows. The core or Beta portfolio for a pension should be in investment grade bonds that cash flow match and fully fund liabilities chronologically thereby buying time for the Alpha assets to outgrow liabilities and erase the deficit. The proper Beta portfolio for any liability objective should be… a Liability Beta Portfolio™. Ryan ALM has developed an LBP which will cash flow match liabilities chronologically and reduce funding costs by about 2% per year (1-10 years = 20%) as well as reduce the volatility of the Funded Status and contribution costs. The LBP should be the core portfolio of any pension and replace active fixed income management. By matching and funding liabilities chronologically, the LBP buys time for the Alpha assets (non-bonds) to perform. By working in harmony with the Alpha assets the plan can gradually enhance its funded status and reduce contribution costs.

Liability Alpha Assets: The non-bond assets are managed vs. the CLI to exceed liability growth (earn liability Alpha) and enhance the economic Funded Status. The goal here is outgrow liabilities in $s (relative returns) by enough to erase the deficit over a time horizon equal to the average life (duration) of liabilities (calculated by the CLI). As the Alpha assets achieve the required annual Alpha, any excess returns vs. liability growth should be ported over to the Liability Beta Portfolio™ to secure the victory. Had this been in place during the decade of the 1990s when pensions had surpluses… there would be no pension crisis today.

“Where is the knowledge we have lost in information”

T.S. Eliot

Ronald J. Ryan, CFA - Chairman

Ron Ryan is Chairman and Founder of Ryan ALM, Inc., which he established in 2004 to help pension plans reduce cost and risk through liability-focused solutions. A pioneer in fixed-income indexing, Ron previously founded Ryan Labs and Ryan Financial Strategy Group and served as Director of Fixed Income Research at Lehman Brothers Kuhn Loeb, where he helped design many of the firm’s widely used bond indexes. His career has been recognized with numerous industry honors, including the William F. Sharpe Indexing Lifetime Achievement Award. Ron is also the author of The U.S. Pension Crisis and holds the CFA® designation, an MBA, and a BBA from Loyola University.

Previous
Previous

Pension Conundrum - Liquidity Risk

Next
Next

Pension Problem: Asset Only Focus