One of the key measurements of the solvency of a pension is the funded ratio, which is simply assets/liabilities. But the valuation of liabilities can be quite controversial, if not erroneous, depending on what discount rate methodology you choose:
FASB 87 = requires high quality bonds as a yield curve (AA corporate zero-coupon bonds)
GASB 67/68 = allows for the return on assets (ROA) assumption
ASOP 4 = low default risk obligation measure (LDROM)
Public pensions are particularly in a confused state as they show both GASB and ASOP valuations on their actuarial reports. The average GASB discount rate was 6.86%. This is in sharp contrast to FASB (ASC 715 discount rate = 5.14%) and Treasury discount rate = 3.95%. The 2023 actuarial reports of the top 100 public pensions bear witness to this contrasting and conflicting valuations:
Unfunded Liabilities
| GASB 67/68 | $1.2 trillion |
| ASOP 4 | $4.5 trillion |
(Source: Piscataqua Research)
Actuarial Standards of Practice (ASOP) are created by the Actuarial Standards Board (ASB) to identify what should be considered and disclosed when rending actuarial services. The ASOPs are binding upon actuaries in the U.S. The first ASOP was adopted in 1986. One of the most controversial actuarial practice areas is the pension discount rate. ASOP #4 was approved and adopted by the ASB in December 2021. It became effective for actuarial reports on or after February 15, 2023. It requires a new way to select a discount rate as follows:
“Section 3.11 Low-Default-Risk Obligation Measure – When performing a funding valuation, the actuary should calculate and disclose a low-default-risk obligation measure of the benefits earned or costs accrued as of the measurement date. The actuary need not calculate and disclose this obligation measure more than once per year.
When calculating this measure, the actuary should select a discount rate derived from low-default-risk fixed income securities whose cash flows are reasonably consistent with the pattern of benefits expected to be paid in the future. Examples of discount rates that may meet these requirements include, but are not limited to, the following:
- U.S. Treasury yields;
- Rates implicit in settlement of pension obligations including payment of lump sums and purchases of annuities from insurance companies;
- Yields on corporate or tax-exempt general obligation municipal bonds that receive one of the two highest ratings given by a recognized ratings agency;
- Non-stabilized ERISA funding rates for single employer plans; and
- Multiemployer current liability rates”
ASOP 4 requires a discount rate(s) based on low-default-risk fixed income securities whose cash flows are consistent with the projected benefits payment schedule. This should mean a yield curve of high-quality zero-coupon bonds who cash flow match the liability cash flows (projected benefit payments). This is the FASB approach to pension discount rates where the discount rates settle or defease the liability cash flows. Under ASC 715 (FASB), AA corporate zero-coupon bonds as a yield curve are used as the discount rates with a single discount rate calculated that matches the present value of liabilities to the future value using this discount rate yield curve. Moody’s has also adopted ASC 715 as the way they will assess the credit rating of municipalities (12/19/17… Adjustments to US State and Local Government Reported Pension Data).
If cash flow matching is a requirement for a discount rate(s) in conformity to ASOP 4 then it seems that only ASC 715 with zero-coupon AA corporates or U.S. Treasury STRIPS meet this standard. No other discount rate option has a term structure or yield curve of certain cash flows. U.S. Treasury STRIPS would produce a much higher liability present value due to the lower interest rates yield curve. Treasury STRIPS would produce a lower funding valuation (Funded Ratio and Funded Status) than ASC 715. As a result, ASC 715 should be favored as the preferred discount rate methodology.
ASC 715 Methodology
Ryan ALM is one of few ASC 715 discount rate vendors. We provide four distinct discount rate yield curves that best conform to FASB GAAP requirements. Each curve is comprised of hypothetical AA corporate zero-coupon bonds from 0.5 - 30+ years to maturity:
| High End Select | (top 10% yielding bonds) |
| Top 1/3 Curve | (top 33% yielding bonds) |
| Above Median Curve | (top 50% yielding bonds) |
| Full Curve | (all 100% yielding bonds) |
Yield curves derived from actual AAA/AA corporate bonds placed into 8 maturity bands:
| 1.01 - 3.00 years | 7.51 - 9.50 years | 24.01 - 27.00 years |
| 3.01 - 5.00 years | 9.51 - 17.00 years | 27.01 + years |
| 5.01 - 7.50 years | 17.01 - 24.00 years |
Parameters of Eight (8) Maturity Bands:
| Ratings | AA+ |
| Minimum Issue | $100 million |
| Currency | U.S. Dollar Denominated |
| Coupon | Non-zero, fixed coupon bonds |
| Maturity Type | Option Free (Non putable or callable) |
| Issue Type | Publicly traded U.S. Corporate bonds |
| Pricing | Excludes bonds priced outside $55 - $145 range |
| Yields | Excludes YTM >2.0 STD from the average YTM |
Benefits
- Ryan ALM discount rates consistently higher than industry
- Offer four distinct discount rate yield curves in conformity to ASC 715
- Ryan ALM discount rates used by Price Waterhouse Coopers and actuarial firms
“Where is the knowledge we have lost in information”
T.S. Eliot