Pension LDI: Cash Flow Matching

The primary pension objective is to secure promised benefits (Retired Lives) in a cost-effective manner (stable to lower contribution costs) with prudent risk. Notably, benefits are future value numbers. As a result, to manage assets vs. benefits would require knowing the future value of assets. Only bond cash flows (future values) are known with certainty. As a result, bond assets are best managed versus Retired Lives which are the most certain and imminent liabilities. Cash flow matching (CFM) is the most appropriate way to manage asset cash flows versus liability cash flows.

Cash Flow Matching (CFM)

A low cost and low risk way to secure benefits is to cash flow match these future value benefit payments (Retired Lives). In the 1960s thru the early 1980s dedication strategies (CFM) with corporate bonds was common and in vogue for pensions. This strategy became less common as accounting rules focused on present values (Funded Ratio and Funded Status) not future values. This led to great confusion as to how to calculate the present value of liabilities (discount rates) and even assets (i.e. smoothing).

In truth, cash flow matching the liability cash flow schedule (benefits + expenses) at low cost is the ideal way to de-risk a pension plan. Ryan ALM spent two years building a liability CFM product, we named and trademarked as the Liability Beta Portfolio™ (LBP). Our LBP is a cost optimization model that fully funds the liability benefit payment schedule chronologically at the lowest cost given the investment policy restrictions of our clients using investment grade bonds skewed to A/BBB+. Bond math suggests that the longer the maturity and the higher the yield… the lower the cost. Our LBP runs several iterations to achieve low cost by skewing the weights to longer maturities and higher-yielding bonds within the liability benefit payment schedule we are funding (i.e. 1-10 years Retired Lives).

The Liability Beta Portfolio (LBP) provides funding cost savings of about 2% per year (1-10 years = 20%, 1-20 years = 40%)! This is a serious cost reduction and should be a major consideration of any de-risking strategy. Yes, the LBP model has some credit risk but very small since we are using investment grade bonds with many credit filters (i.e. no bonds on negative watch lists and several solvency tests) plus the cost savings provides a large value-added cushion.

The funded ratio should dictate the allocation to bonds, which in turn will determine how much of the liabilities we can CFM (i.e. 15% bond allocation might fund the next seven to 10-years of Net Retired Lives). We recommend funding at least the next 10 years of Retired Lives on a net liability basis (after contributions). Indeed, contributions are the first source to fund liabilities such that current assets fund the net liabilities (after contributions) not the gross liabilities. Our LBP model will calculate with precision the cost to fund liabilities (gross or net) in a cost-effective manner chronologically. Since liabilities are funded initially by contributions, using the LBP model to cash flow match net liabilities chronologically may be able to fund more liabilities than you think. Assume that a 15% bond allocation could match the next 10-years of net Retired Lives benefit payments chronologically. Based on the Ryan ALM Liability Beta Portfolio™ (LBP) model we show a cost savings of about 20% on cash flow matching the first 10 years of net liabilities versus the projected net Retired Lives (projected benefits – projected contributions).

Matching liabilities chronologically should also buy time for the non-bond assets (Alpha assets) to perform and outgrow Active Lives liabilities. Given time (10-years) most non-bond asset classes tend to outperform bonds. Since liabilities behave like bonds there is a high probability that non-bond asset classes could outperform liability growth over an extended time horizon. This would enhance the funded status allowing for reduced contribution costs or increased Active Lives benefits or both. Our LBP has numerous benefits that best achieve the true pension objective:

Secures Benefits

Cash flow matches + funds monthly Retired Lives benefits chronologically

Enhances Funded Ratio /Status

LBP outyields Liability discount rate (ASC 715) @ 50 - 100 bps… creates Alpha

Reduces Costs

LBP reduces Contribution, Funding and Asset Management Costs
LBP outyields liabilities thereby creating Alpha, which enhances Funded Ratio
LBP reduces asset management costs (low fees)

Reduces Volatility

Liability Beta Portfolio matches and funds liability benefit payments
Reduces Volatility of Funded Ratio/Funded Status
Reduces Volatility of Contribution Costs

Reduces Risk

Risk = Uncertainty of Funding Benefit Payments (LBP funds with certainty)
Benefit Payments are Future Values (FV have No Interest Rate Sensitive)

Enhances ROA

LBP composition: Investment Grade corporates (skewed to A/BBB+)
LBP should outyield most active management bond portfolios

Benefit: Buys Time

Moves any deficit out longer extending the investment horizon
Liability Beta Portfolio™ fully funds Liabilities Chronologically
Buys Time for Non-bond Assets (Alpha assets) to outgrow Liabilities
Non-bond Assets Outperform Bonds (Liabilities) over Long Horizons

Future Value (FV) vs. Present Value (PV)

Actuarial practices use present values (PV) to calculate the funded ratio and funded status. But benefit payments are future values (FV). This suggests that the future value of assets vs. the future value of liabilities is the most critical evaluation. But most asset classes are difficult to ascertain their future value. This is why the PV is used. Only bonds have a known future value and have historically been used to cash flow match liabilities (i.e. defeasance, dedication). To prove my point as to the potential misinformation with using a PV calculation, let’s use a simple example below. Two pensions each have a $1.0 billion market value and thus have the same funded ratio in PV$. Pension A is invested 100% in Treasuries while pension B is 100% invested in A and BBB corporate bonds (with the same maturities and par values) that outyield pension A by 100 bps per year. Certainly, plan B has a much greater future value (@ 20% higher) and funded status if we used future values. This suggests that the funded ratio and funded status are not that accurate or even good indicators of the true economic solvency:

Pension Composition YTM PV FV
A 100% Treasuries 4.50% $1.0 billion $1.5 billion
B 100% Corporates 5.50% $1.0 billion $1.8 billion

The point of all this is… that we need to focus more on the FV of assets vs. liabilities. A corporate bond portfolio cash flow matched to liabilities that outyields liabilities would enhance the funded ratio on a future value basis thereby reducing funding costs (i.e. contribution costs) while securing benefits. This is why “cash flow matching” of liability future values is the most prudent risk and lowest cost methodology to de-risking a pension through asset liability management (ALM).

For more info, contact: Russ Kamp – CEO at rkamp@ryanalm.com

Ronald J. Ryan, CFA - Chairman

Ron Ryan is Chairman and Founder of Ryan ALM, Inc., which he established in 2004 to help pension plans reduce cost and risk through liability-focused solutions. A pioneer in fixed-income indexing, Ron previously founded Ryan Labs and Ryan Financial Strategy Group and served as Director of Fixed Income Research at Lehman Brothers Kuhn Loeb, where he helped design many of the firm’s widely used bond indexes. His career has been recognized with numerous industry honors, including the William F. Sharpe Indexing Lifetime Achievement Award. Ron is also the author of The U.S. Pension Crisis and holds the CFA® designation, an MBA, and a BBA from Loyola University.

Next
Next

Pension Benchmarks: the Good, the Bad, the Ugly